Japan’s government estimated last December that a major earthquake directly beneath southern central Tokyo could kill about 18,000 people and cause about 83 trillion yen in economic damage, a worst-case scenario that illustrates why dense cities plan for earthquakes years in advance.

The working group report, prepared under Japan’s Central Disaster Management Council, also projected about 400,000 buildings destroyed or burned, 4.8 million evacuees and 8.4 million people unable to get home. It estimated a further 16,000 to 41,000 disaster-related deaths and noted that its figures are calculations made under set conditions.

Three cities show how differently that risk can be approached: Tokyo has concentrated on fire and roads, San Francisco on one weak type of housing, and Mexico City on warning time.

Tokyo: keeping roads open and fire contained

After the 1995 Great Hanshin-Awaji Earthquake, the Tokyo Metropolitan Government drew up an Urban Development Plan for Disaster-Resistance in 1996, according to its urban development bureau. The plan, revised in 2016, centers on firebreak belts, protected disaster response routes, evacuation areas and the improvement of districts of close-set wooden houses.

The city tracks a fire-resistant area ratio and says that above 70% there is almost no danger of fire spreading in a built-up area. It also requires owners of certain buildings along designated emergency routes to report their seismic status and undergo assessments, so that collapsed structures do not block rescue and supply traffic. Evaluations are generally free, and subsidies can cover up to 90% of retrofit costs.

Progress is published. Tokyo’s resilience portal reported an overall achievement rate of 94.2% for buildings along those routes at the end of June 2026, up from 91.1% at the end of December 2019.

San Francisco: fixing a known weak point

San Francisco’s approach targets one building type. Its soft-story ordinance, adopted in April 2013, covers older wood-frame buildings with five or more dwelling units and three or more stories, or two stories over a basement or crawl space, that were permitted before 1978 and had not been strengthened, structural engineer John Dal Pino wrote in STRUCTURE magazine.

The 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake exposed the vulnerability of such soft and weak first stories. A 2016 Association of Bay Area Governments report counted 6,700 soft-story buildings in the city, more than in the rest of the region combined. About 3,300 retrofit permits were issued from 2015 to 2017, and the article put straightforward projects at $20,000 to $25,000 per unit.

Mexico City: buying seconds

Mexico’s Seismic Alert System, known as SASMEX, began operating in August 1991 and in August 1993 became the first early warning system to broadcast alerts openly to the public, according to a 2022 review by Gerardo Suárez of the National Autonomous University of Mexico. It uses 97 dedicated sensors, and Suárez estimates that about 25 million people receive its alerts.

Distance determines its value. Suárez cites at least 50 seconds of warning in Mexico City for subduction earthquakes. In the magnitude 7.1 earthquake of Sept. 19, 2017, centered about 100 kilometers to the south, the alert sounded at the same time as strong shaking or a few seconds after it.

The idea that building safety, roads and open space belong in one plan also appears in commentary on urban renewal. The news section of the website of Egemen Mustafa Sener, for example, lists an article on earthquake risk that frames housing, transport and green space as one system.

Why it matters

The three approaches address different stages of a disaster: stronger buildings and firebreaks limit damage, protected routes keep rescuers moving, and alerts buy time. Warning alone has limits. Suárez writes that evacuating at the alert is impractical in high-rise buildings and crowded venues, and that official protocols for institutions and building types are largely missing.

Costs also fall unevenly. In San Francisco, public financing lets owners pass retrofit and financing costs to tenants, subject to Rent Board approval for rent-controlled properties, according to the STRUCTURE article. Japan’s report calls on households to retrofit homes, secure furniture and install seismic circuit breakers, and on companies to prepare business continuity plans.

The caveats

Japan’s figures are maximum estimates calculated under set conditions, not forecasts of a specific event. Tokyo’s achievement rate covers only buildings along designated routes. Tokyo’s subsidy terms and the San Francisco permit and cost figures come from undated documents and may have changed since they were written.

Corrections and tips: email the editor using the address on the Contact page.